From My Time on the Condo Board
Three Months in a Hotel Because Our Board Couldn't Agree
A few months after our new board was elected, a pipe burst inside a wall in one of the units. Our building is about 50 years old and has around 250 units, so leaks were nothing new. This one was bad, though. The water went down through several floors, and the unit directly under the pipe took most of the damage: ceiling, walls and floors. Two or three units further down were affected too, but less seriously. The worst one was no longer livable, and the owner's insurance company put him up in a hotel.
He ended up living there for almost three months.
The water was shut off quickly, so the leak itself was under control. All that was left was repairing the damage, and that part should not have taken long. But our property management company kept bringing different repair proposals to the board. We met once a month, so every new proposal pushed the decision back another month. The contractor management wanted to use quoted more than $20,000 for all the affected units.
I suggested another option. We had a handyman who was already doing repairs in the building, and I had seen enough of his work to know he could handle this job.
Most of the directors voted against him, and it wasn't really about his skills. A few of them suspected he was connected to me and that I would get some kind of kickback for bringing him in. There was nothing like that, but it's hard to prove you're not getting something. And as president, I had no authority to hire anyone over the board's objection.
What finally moved things was that the other directors met with him themselves. They saw that he had a business licence and commercial liability insurance, asked their questions and formed their own opinion. After that they agreed to let him do the work. He repaired all the units for about $7,000, roughly a third of the contractor's price, and the work was done properly. Three years later he was still working in our building.
Looking back, most of the delay was on management. Organizing a repair like this is their job, and they should have moved much faster. But the board wasn't blameless either. We let a question of trust hold up a decision about repairs, and I wasn't able to get us past it sooner.
The decision we made in the end was the one that had been on the table from the start. The only thing the delay changed was that an owner spent three months in a hotel instead of his own home.
What I would do differently
I would put it in writing at the very first discussion that I had no financial connection to the handyman. A written statement in the minutes is easier for other directors to accept than verbal assurances. I would also ask management for two or three quotes at the same time, instead of reviewing one proposal per meeting. And I would push for a special board meeting rather than waiting a month. When an owner can't live in his home, that is reason enough to meet sooner.
Want a personal review of your situation?
Get a written review from Alexander Baraz of what your documents mean and what your options are, before you pay, respond, or escalate.
Not ready yet? Start with the Free Notice Decoder.
Related guides
Independent guidance for Ontario condo owners. Not legal advice. Not legal representation. Not an engineering opinion. It is not a substitute for advice about your specific situation from a licensed professional. Condo Owner Advocate helps you understand your situation. You decide what to do.
