From My Time on the Condo Board
A $20,000 Fix for an Old Machine, or $18,000 for a New One
When I became president of our condo board, one of the problems we inherited was the garbage compactor. Our building has a garbage chute on every floor. Garbage falls into a room at the bottom, and every time a bag lands, the compactor starts up automatically and runs for a while. It was loud, and the people living above the garbage room heard it every time.
The issue came back to the board when our new property management company brought us an engineering report that the previous board had ordered. The engineers recommended installing vibration isolators under the compactor to cut down the noise travelling through the structure. The estimate was about $20,000. The compactor was at least ten years old and long out of warranty. We would be putting $20,000 into an old machine, and afterward we would still have an old machine.
Before deciding anything, another director and I went door to door in the units above the garbage room. Residents in five units told us the noise bothered them, mostly at night. Someone upstairs would throw out a bag at midnight, the compactor would kick in, and the people below would wake up.
I contacted three companies that supply, install and service compactors and asked each for a quote. When I brought the proposals to the board, the best option turned out to be a new compactor with its own vibration isolators and a three-year warranty, for about $18,000. That was less than the isolation work on the old one alone. The board approved the replacement, and the new machine was so quiet that the noise problem was basically gone.
We did one more thing, and it cost nothing. Management put up notices by the chutes on every floor asking residents not to use them between 10 p.m. and 8 a.m. People mostly respected it, and the night-time complaints stopped.
The engineers weren’t wrong. Vibration isolation was the right idea, and our new compactor has it. But they were asked how to make the existing machine quieter, and nobody asked whether a ten-year-old machine was worth that kind of money. Before a board approves an expensive repair, it’s worth checking what a replacement would cost. Sometimes it’s about the same. In our case, it was less.
Want a personal review of your situation?
Get a written review from Alexander Baraz of what your documents mean and what your options are, before you pay, respond, or escalate.
Not ready yet? Start with the Free Notice Decoder.
Related guides
Independent guidance for Ontario condo owners. Not legal advice. Not legal representation. Not an engineering opinion. It is not a substitute for advice about your specific situation from a licensed professional. Condo Owner Advocate helps you understand your situation. You decide what to do.
